If you’re a true cheese lover, there’s nothing more exciting than discovering a new, flavorful wedge that tells a story. While imported cheeses often get the spotlight, America’s artisanal cheese scene is flourishing, producing unique, small-batch varieties that celebrate local ingredients and craftsmanship. Today, we invite you to explore some lesser-known American artisanal cow’s milk cheeses, their origins, flavor profiles and perfect pairing suggestions to elevate your next tasting experience.
-
Rush Creek Reserve – Uplands Cheese, Wisconsin
Hailing from the rolling hills of Dodgeville, Wisconsin, Rush Creek Reserve is a seasonal cheese inspired by France’s famous Vacherin Mont d’Or. Wrapped in spruce bark, this rich and creamy cheese is only available in the fall and early winter, making it a highly anticipated treat. Its spoonable interior is savory with hints of woodsy earthiness.
Pairing Suggestions: Enjoy it with crusty sourdough bread, roasted garlic and caramelized onions. For a refreshing beverage pairing, try chilled apple cider, a lightly brewed herbal tea like chamomile or a crisp, dry crisp, dry Riesling to balance its decadent creaminess.
-
Coppinger – Sequatchie Cove Creamery, Tennessee
From the heart of the Appalachian Mountains, Coppinger is a Southern gem reminiscent of a French Tomme. This semi-soft cheese boasts a washed rind and a buttery, fruity flavor with subtle notes of roasted nuts. Its vibrant orange rind adds visual appeal to any cheese board.
Pairing Suggestions: Complement Coppinger with dried apricots, candied pecans and fresh figs. A chilled sparkling water with a hint of citrus or a glass of light-bodied Pinot Noir makes a delightful pairing to highlight the cheeses complex flavors.
-
Green Hill – Sweet Grass Dairy, Georgia
Green Hill is a double-cream, soft-ripened cheese that offers a luxurious, velvety texture and a delicate, buttery flavor. Produced in Thomasville, Georgia, this cheese is made from grass-fed cow’s milk, giving it a fresh, clean finish.
Pairing Suggestions: Spread it on warm baguette slices and top with a drizzle of local honey or fresh berries. Complement its creaminess with a glass of sparkling wine or a cold glass of lemonade.
-
Eden – Tulip Tree Creamery, Indiana
Eden is a unique blend of bloomy and washed rind styles, resulting in a soft, creamy interior with a slightly funky aroma and a tangy, savory flavor. Produced in Indianapolis, Indiana, this cheese pushes the boundaries of traditional cow’s milk varieties.
Pairing Suggestions: Serve Eden alongside spiced nuts, thinly sliced prosciutto and roasted red peppers. For a beverage, consider a bold ginger beer, an amber ale or a tart cranberry spritzer to cut through the richness.
-
Red Rock – Roelli Cheese Haus, Wisconsin
For those who love a visual showstopper, Red Rock is a must-try. This striking cheese combines the creamy texture of a cheddar with the bold character of a blue cheese. Its bright orange color and signature blue veins create a dramatic look on any platter.
Pairing Suggestions: Enjoy Red Rock with crisp apple or pear slices, toasted walnut bread and dark chocolate squares. A robust black tea, a dark stout or a smoky bourbon makes an excellent accompaniment for this bold-flavored cheese.
Final Thoughts
Exploring American artisanal cheeses is like taking a flavorful journey through the country’s rich dairy traditions. These small-batch creations not only highlight the dedication of passionate cheesemakers but also offer an incredible array of tastes and textures. Whether you’re planning an intimate wine and cheese night or simply looking to expand your palate, these hidden gems of the cheese world are sure to impress.